Over 1/3 of finance professionals felt vulnerable in last 12 months

A recent Chartered Body Alliance global survey has revealed some realities regarding the treatment of customers in vulnerable circumstances, including that 33 per cent of respondents working in financial services considered themselves to be vulnerable within the last 12 months.

The survey was undertaken by Chartered Body Alliance members between 4th August – 8th September 2021. A total of 1,637 responses were received.

Over the past 12 months, most respondents (61%) said that they had either directly or indirectly supported a customer in vulnerable circumstances, while 75 per cent had discussed the issues facing such customers within their team, either frequently or on occasion.

Respondents were asked if they had seen any examples of bad practice towards customers in vulnerable circumstances. Detailed, anonymous examples were provided by 356 respondents and included:

  • elderly customers being directed to online complaint forms
  • pushy salespeople
  • misuse and lack of knowledge of lasting powers of attorney and Court of Protection orders
  • overuse of automation and AI and a lack of availability of telephone contact
  • a lack of empathy for bereaved customers
  • poor response to instances of scamming and fraud
  • lack of sensitivity to customers’ physical disabilities.

When asked about their firm's policies and procedures around the treatment of customers in vulnerable circumstances, almost four-fifths (80%) said that their organisation does have policies and procedures in place, while just over 10 per cent did not.

However, a significantly lower percentage (58%) had received formal, structured training on the fair treatment of customers in vulnerable circumstances. Of those who had undergone training, only half (51%) had received it in the six months prior to the survey.

Two-thirds (65%) of respondents said their organisation had a formal definition of what is considered to be a customer in vulnerable circumstances, with just over half (55%) believing that their firm’s definition aligned closely with the FCA’s. A clear majority of respondents (74%) had no concerns about their ability to implement the FCA’s guidance, with just 6 per cent saying that they did have such concerns. However, 12 per cent said they were ‘somewhat’ concerned.

Simon Culhane, CISI CEO Chartered FCSI said, “our report shows that most professionals are seriously addressing their duties and responsibilities in this area as outlined in the FCA Guidance.

“But there is more to be done, as we can see from the examples cited as unacceptable, bad practices towards customers. Lack of empathy, overuse of automation and poor communication are themes we must address. The FCA Consumer Duty proposals specifically state that regulated firms should ‘put themselves in the shoes of others.’ We acknowledge the gaps in knowledge, skills, and behaviour which this survey has highlighted. We will start this process by producing a Chartered Body Alliance toolkit and a series of events for 2022, with round tables for well-being leads in member firms, to open the discussion on this survey outcome.

“The fact that 33 per cent of respondents working in financial services also considered themselves vulnerable within the past 12 months has emphasised the importance of looking after our own member practitioners. We will be examining how we can expand the CISI mental health portal to further support financial services professionals in this respect.”

Simon Thompson, Chartered Banker Institute Chief Executive added, “We welcome the findings of this report, which gives us some great insights into how our members feel about the treatment of their customers in vulnerable circumstances. Over the past 18 months, we’ve all faced the very real challenges of supporting customers, colleagues, loved ones – and ourselves - through the series of challenges presented by Covid. Yet throughout this difficult period, banks, and bankers – and the members of the Chartered Body Alliance in particular - have continued to play key roles in helping to rebuild businesses, communities, and personal finances. During this period, we offered several free resources to assist our members in their day-to-day roles in dealing with vulnerable customers; but as these findings reveal, more needs to be done, and we encourage all employers to work with us to step up the training required, whilst also considering their employees’ wellbeing needs.”

More News
11 hours ago
Five tips for a January financial health check
Taking timely action to review your spending and think about how you manage your money can help you start the year with your finances on track, according to a Coventry University expert.
12 hours ago
Siemens provides top tips for a greener, more sustainable 2022
Decarbonisation is a journey, and, like all journeys, it starts with making the first step and then the next. The critical thing is to start the journey and to start now. This is according to Carl Ennis, CEO of Siemens UK. Siemens globally has reduced its carbon footprint by more than 50 per cent in its manufacturing emissions over the past 6 years on its journey to carbon zero by 2030.
1 day ago
BT seals data centre deal with BAI Communications for London Underground
BT has announced the signing of a multi-million-pound contract with BAI Communications (BAI), to deliver a core part of the company’s data centre requirements as it works with Transport for London (TfL) to enable high-speed mobile and Wi-Fi coverage on the London Underground.
1 day ago
Hybrid working model best for mental health
Employees who can split their working time between home and a formal workplace are 40 per cent less likely to experience mental health difficulties, new research has shown.
2 days ago
MPS Monitor integrates PaperCut data
MPS Monitor has announced the integration of PaperCut MF and Papercut NG print management data into its Analytics BI platform. The goal of this integration is to provide a feature-rich Business Intelligence and reporting environment to imaging dealers and Managed Print Services end customers who use the PaperCut MF and Papercut NG platforms for print management, job accounting, and secure printing.
3 days ago
Sharp expands half-cut cell portfolio with new panels
Sharp has announced the addition of the new 410W and 400W monocrystalline PERC silicon photovoltaic panels to its half-cut cell portfolio, the NU-JC410 and its all-black version the NU-JC400B.
4 days ago
Enterprises looking to hybrid multi-cloud
Nutanix has announced the UK-specific findings of its fourth global Enterprise Cloud Index (ECI) survey and research report, which measures enterprise progress with cloud adoption.
1 week ago
Cyberattack surge causing havoc for UK professional services organisations
Professional services companies in the UK have experienced 62 cyberattacks in the last 12 months, one every six days, according to new research by Keeper Security. The company's 2021 Cybersecurity Census Report has also revealed that almost half (48%) of IT decision-makers working at professional services companies have kept a cybersecurity attack on their organisation to themselves, raising questions about how badly affected businesses really are by these attacks. 
1 week ago
HP introduces devices for blended learning environments
HP Inc has introduced HP Fortis laptops, a new portfolio of PCs built to withstand the rigours of education environments.
1 week ago
Multicloud is here to stay, but complexity and challenges remain
Nutanix, experts in hybrid multi-cloud computing, has announced the findings of its fourth global Enterprise Cloud Index (ECI) survey and research report, which measures enterprise progress with cloud adoption.

Login / Sign up